From Australian sf information
Jump to: navigation, search

Talk:2011 Ditmar eligibility list

513 bytes added, 10:06, 20 February 2011
Clarification of moving and strikethrough of nominations
:The rule says "a work or related work". --[[User:Thomas Bull|Thomas Bull]] 18:01, 16 February 2011 (UTC)
::As it stands, the rules say (effectively) "a single work". However, I think the ''intent'' was a work or group of related works. (The "related" might have two meanings: the alternate interpretation, that it refers to a work ''related to the genre'', seems less likely than the drafting error of substituting the singular for the plural in "work".) — [[User:Jeremygbyrne|JEREMY]] 23:54, 18 February 2011 (UTC)
:'''Use of Strikethrough or moving nominations''' Can I refer all editors to the discussion above where Jeremy clearly states "Once nominations are made, the DitSubCom will independently adjudicate eligibility". My interpretation off this is that editors should not be using strikethrough or moving nominations to other categories unless requested by the nominee -- it is not up to the editors to determine eligibility but the Ditmar SubCom. [[User:Punkrocker1991|Punkrocker1991]] 10:06, 20 February 2011 (UTC)

Navigation menu